This question consists of a statement and two conclusions in the form of and. You have to assume that everything in the statement is true, then consider the two conclusions together and decide which of them logically follows from the information given in the statement beyond any doubt.

Statement: Everyone who lives in Madrid must keep a dog. John lives in Madrid.

Conclusions:

i). John has a dog.

ii). Amy, who lives in Madrid, does not have a dog.

Choose the most appropriate one from the following options:

A. Only conclusion i follows.

B. Only conclusion ii follows.

C. Either conclusion i or ii follows.

D. Neither conclusion i nor ii follows.

E. Both conclusions i and ii follow.

This question was previously asked in
RPF SI (2018) Official Paper (Held On: 19 Dec 2018 Shift 3)
View all RPF SI Papers >
  1. D
  2. A
  3. E
  4. C

Answer (Detailed Solution Below)

Option 2 : A
Free
RPF SI Full Mock Test
2.2 Lakh Users
120 Questions 120 Marks 90 Mins

Detailed Solution

Download Solution PDF

Given,

Statement:

Everyone who lives in Madrid must keep a dog. John lives in Madrid.

Conclusions:

I. John has a dog - True (Because, the statement mentions that everyone who lives in Madrid must keep a dog, and since John lives in Madrid, he must have a dog).

II. Amy, who lives in Madrid, does not have a dog - False (Because, the statement mentions that everyone who lives in Madrid must keep a dog. Therefore, if Amy lives in Madrid, she must have a dog).

So, Only conclusion I follows.

Hence, the correct answer is "Option 2".

Latest RPF SI Updates

Last updated on Jun 7, 2025

-> RPF SI Physical Test Admit Card 2025 has been released on the official website. The PMT and PST is scheduled from 22nd June 2025 to 2nd July 2025. 

-> This Dates are for the previous cycle of RPF SI Recruitment.

-> Indian Ministry of Railways will release the RPF Recruitment 2025 notification for the post of Sub-Inspector (SI).

-> The vacancies and application dates will be announced for the RPF Recruitment 2025 on the official website. Also, RRB ALP 2025 Notification was released. 

-> The selection process includes CBT, PET & PMT, and Document Verification. Candidates need to pass all the stages to get selected in the RPF SI Recruitment 2025. 

-> Prepare for the exam with RPF SI Previous Year Papers and boost your score in the examination. 

More Statements and Conclusions Questions

Get Free Access Now
Hot Links: teen patti wealth dhani teen patti teen patti all game teen patti earning app